| SCO D2 | 25 Mar 04:00 | ||||
| [None]East Fife |  | None:None |  | Elgin City[None] |
| Fixture | ||||
| Overall | ||
| East Fife Wins | Draws | Elgin City Wins |
| 19 | 2 | 10 |
| Statistics | ||
| East Fife | Statistics | Elgin City |
| 19 | Total Wins | 10 |
| 10 | Home Wins | 5 |
| 9 | Away Wins | 5 |
| 63 | Total Goals | 50 |
| 31 | Home Goals | 30 |
| 32 | Away Goals | 20 |
| 2.0 | Av Scored Per Game | 1.6 |
| 1.8 | Av Scored Per Game Home | 2.1 |
| 2.3 | Av Scored Per Game Away | 1.2 |
| Record | League | Date | Home | Score | Away |
| Biggest Aggregate | Scottish League Two | 04 Feb 2006 | Elgin City | 5 - 3 | East Fife |
| Biggest East Fife scored | Scottish League Two | 04 Mar 2015 | Elgin City | 3 - 5 | East Fife |
| Biggest Elgin City scored | Scottish League Two | 04 Feb 2006 | Elgin City | 5 - 3 | East Fife |
| League | Date | Home | Score | Away |
| Scottish League Two | 07 Jan 2023 | Elgin City | 1 - 2(HT:0-2) | East Fife |
| Scottish League Two | 29 Oct 2022 | East Fife | 2 - 1(HT:1 - 0) | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 30 Jul 2022 | Elgin City | 1 - 3(HT:0 - 2) | East Fife |
| Scottish League Cup | 24 Jul 2021 | East Fife | 2 - 3(HT:2 - 2) | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Cup | 26 Jul 2017 | East Fife | 3 - 2(HT:0 - 0) | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 05 Mar 2016 | Elgin City | 1 - 3(HT:1 - 2) | East Fife |
| Scottish League Two | 02 Jan 2016 | East Fife | 0 - 2(HT:0 - 0) | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 21 Nov 2015 | Elgin City | 4 - 2(HT:2 - 2) | East Fife |
| Scottish League Two | 22 Aug 2015 | East Fife | 2 - 1(HT:1 - 1) | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 02 May 2015 | East Fife | 3 - 1(HT:1 - 0) | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 04 Mar 2015 | Elgin City | 3 - 5(HT:1 - 4) | East Fife |
| Scottish League Two | 22 Nov 2014 | East Fife | 1 - 1(HT:1 - 1) | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 09 Aug 2014 | Elgin City | 1 - 0(HT:0 - 0) | East Fife |
| Scottish Cup | 03 Nov 2012 | Elgin City | 5 - 1(HT:2 - 0) | East Fife |
| Scottish Bells Challenge Cup | 10 Aug 2011 | East Fife | 2 - 0(HT:0 - 0) | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Cup | 30 Jul 2011 | East Fife | 2 - 1(HT:0 - 0) | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 23 Feb 2008 | East Fife | 2 - 0(HT:0 - 0) | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 05 Jan 2008 | Elgin City | 1 - 2(HT:0 - 1) | East Fife |
| Scottish League Two | 03 Nov 2007 | East Fife | 4 - 0(HT:1 - 0) | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 18 Aug 2007 | Elgin City | 2 - 3(HT:1 - 1) | East Fife |
| Scottish League Two | 03 Mar 2007 | East Fife | 3 - 1(HT:2 - 1) | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 04 Nov 2006 | East Fife | 1 - 1(HT:1 - 0) | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 07 Oct 2006 | Elgin City | 2 - 3(HT:0 - 1) | East Fife |
| Scottish League Two | 26 Aug 2006 | Elgin City | 1 - 2(HT:0 - 0) | East Fife |
| Scottish League Two | 01 Apr 2006 | East Fife | 0 - 2(HT:0 - 1) | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 04 Feb 2006 | Elgin City | 5 - 3(HT:2 - 2) | East Fife |
| Scottish League Two | 07 Jan 2006 | East Fife | 1 - 2(HT:0 - 0) | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 01 Oct 2005 | Elgin City | 1 - 2(HT:0 - 1) | East Fife |
| Scottish League Two | 09 Apr 2005 | East Fife | 1 - 2(HT:1 - 1) | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 26 Mar 2005 | East Fife | 2 - 0(HT:0 - 0) | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 12 Feb 2005 | Elgin City | 2 - 1(HT:1 - 0) | East Fife |
| League | Date | Home | Score | Away |
| Scottish League Two | 18 Mar 2023 | Bonnyrigg Rose | 1-1(0-0) | East Fife |
| Scottish League Two | 11 Mar 2023 | Stenhousemuir | 1-2(1-0) | East Fife |
| Scottish League Two | 04 Mar 2023 | East Fife | 3-2(1-1) | Forfar Athletic |
| Scottish League Two | 25 Feb 2023 | Stranraer F.C. | 2-0(1-0) | East Fife |
| Scottish League Two | 18 Feb 2023 | East Fife | 2-0(1-0) | Dumbarton |
| League | Date | Home | Score | Away |
| Scottish League Two | 11 Mar 2023 | Annan Athletic | 4-1(2-1) | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 04 Mar 2023 | Elgin City | 0-1(0-0) | Bonnyrigg Rose |
| Scottish League Two | 25 Feb 2023 | Dumbarton | 1-2(1-1) | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 18 Feb 2023 | Elgin City | 0-1(0-1) | Stranraer F.C. |
| Scottish League Two | 04 Feb 2023 | Elgin City | 1-1(0-1) | Albion Rovers FC |
| League | Date | Home | Score | Away |
| Scottish League Two | 25 Mar 2023 | East Fife | VS | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 01 Apr 2023 | East Fife | VS | Annan Athletic |
| Scottish League Two | 08 Apr 2023 | Stirling Albion | VS | East Fife |
| Scottish League Two | 15 Apr 2023 | East Fife | VS | Stranraer F.C. |
| Scottish League Two | 22 Apr 2023 | Dumbarton | VS | East Fife |
| League | Date | Home | Score | Away |
| Scottish League Two | 05 Apr 2023 | Stirling Albion | VS | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 12 Apr 2023 | Elgin City | VS | Stenhousemuir |
| Scottish League Two | 25 Mar 2023 | East Fife | VS | Elgin City |
| Scottish League Two | 01 Apr 2023 | Elgin City | VS | Stirling Albion |
| Scottish League Two | 08 Apr 2023 | Albion Rovers FC | VS | Elgin City |