| League | Date | Home | Score | Away |
| English Football League Trophy | 21 Sep 2022 | Grimsby Town | 2 - 0(HT:2 - 0) | Mansfield Town |
| International Club Friendly | 20 Jul 2021 | Mansfield Town | 0 - 1(HT:0 - 0) | Grimsby Town |
| English Football League Two | 20 Mar 2021 | Mansfield Town | 2 - 2(HT:1 - 0) | Grimsby Town |
| English Football League Two | 12 Dec 2020 | Grimsby Town | 1 - 1(HT:0 - 0) | Mansfield Town |
| English Football League Two | 04 Jan 2020 | Mansfield Town | 0 - 1(HT:0 - 0) | Grimsby Town |
| English Football League Two | 05 Oct 2019 | Grimsby Town | 0 - 1(HT:0 - 0) | Mansfield Town |
| English Football League Two | 01 Jan 2019 | Grimsby Town | 0 - 1(HT:0 - 1) | Mansfield Town |
| English Football League Two | 07 Nov 2018 | Mansfield Town | 2 - 1(HT:0 - 1) | Grimsby Town |
| English Football League Two | 26 Dec 2017 | Grimsby Town | 1 - 1(HT:1 - 0) | Mansfield Town |
| English Football League Two | 09 Sep 2017 | Mansfield Town | 4 - 1(HT:1 - 0) | Grimsby Town |
| English Football League Two | 18 Feb 2017 | Grimsby Town | 3 - 0(HT:1 - 0) | Mansfield Town |
| English Football League Two | 24 Sep 2016 | Mansfield Town | 0 - 1(HT:0 - 1) | Grimsby Town |
| International Club Friendly | 26 Jul 2014 | Grimsby Town | 0 - 1(HT:0 - 1) | Mansfield Town |
| English National League | 13 Mar 2013 | Mansfield Town | 2 - 0(HT:0 - 0) | Grimsby Town |
| English National League | 27 Aug 2012 | Grimsby Town | 4 - 1(HT:2 - 0) | Mansfield Town |
| English National League | 07 Dec 2011 | Grimsby Town | 0 - 0(HT:0 - 0) | Mansfield Town |
| English National League | 08 Oct 2011 | Mansfield Town | 2 - 1(HT:0 - 1) | Grimsby Town |
| English National League | 20 Apr 2011 | Mansfield Town | 0 - 2(HT:0 - 1) | Grimsby Town |
| English National League | 01 Jan 2011 | Grimsby Town | 7 - 2(HT:2 - 1) | Mansfield Town |
| English Football League Two | 22 Mar 2008 | Mansfield Town | 1 - 2(HT:0 - 1) | Grimsby Town |
| English Football League Two | 15 Dec 2007 | Grimsby Town | 1 - 0(HT:0 - 0) | Mansfield Town |
| English Football League Two | 17 Feb 2007 | Mansfield Town | 1 - 2(HT:1 - 1) | Grimsby Town |
| English Football League Trophy | 01 Nov 2006 | Mansfield Town | 3 - 0(HT:1 - 0) | Grimsby Town |
| English Football League Two | 19 Aug 2006 | Grimsby Town | 1 - 1(HT:0 - 0) | Mansfield Town |
| English Football League Two | 15 Feb 2006 | Mansfield Town | 2 - 1(HT:2 - 0) | Grimsby Town |
| English Football League Two | 14 Jan 2006 | Grimsby Town | 2 - 1(HT:1 - 0) | Mansfield Town |
| English Football League Two | 02 Apr 2005 | Mansfield Town | 2 - 0(HT:1 - 0) | Grimsby Town |
| English Football League Two | 28 Aug 2004 | Grimsby Town | 2 - 0(HT:1 - 0) | Mansfield Town |
